Conditio sine qua non

Condition sine qua non

The conditio sine qua non is the test applied to determine whether an event constituted a necessary condition for the occurrence of the damage or the consequence. Absent that event, the consequence would not have occurred.

The conditio sine qua non constitutes the fundamental test for causation in Dutch liability and criminal law. It requires that the damage or consequence would not have occurred had the act or omission in question not taken place.

This criterion is significant because it serves as the initial filter in establishing liability. Only once the conditio sine qua non has been satisfied may other requirements, such as attribution on grounds of reasonableness and fairness or adequate causation, be considered.

In practice, the test is regularly applied in medical liability cases and road traffic accidents to determine whether particular conduct actually caused the damage.

“The court held that the contractor's fault constituted the conditio sine qua non for the collapse of the building.”

Need legal advice?

Schedule a free consultation with one of our specialists